Is this rewall or not?

Short description:
I capped London. My stack got walled in with 3 unit wall (wf was bugged and didn't work, but it doesn't matter now).
Next turn 3 unit wall is removed and this bigwall was made.

Is it considered as rewall or not? I don't have clear answer on it, so place your opinions

Rewall legit lol

If it's a rewall i swear i might have 70% of my duels deleted

Mecoy would say it's a rewall because it's "close" to the original wall.

Napisano od Lelouch., 01.06.2021 at 14:38

Mecoy would say it's a rewall because it's "close" to the original wall.

The new units were literally on the path of prevouis triangle wall units. I don't know what makes such difference between this and actual units swap.
The outcome is totally same...

REWALL BAN THIS SHIT METHOD ITS DIRTY I HATE IT

I myself 10/10 times i would consider this a rewall
and even if you are one of those who deny that it is a rewall, its just such a dick move, the space there is so tiny...

1 unit is at the same place and he removed his first wall this is a rewall

It's not just close the units would merge lol

Not a rewall and rewalls shouldn't be called rewalls they should be called moving units like a normal player

Funny how kids who say rewall here do this multiple times.

The units of the new wall should be at least one city away from the walled city in my opinion.
Maybe like this: (For London, Berlin and Ankara)

Napisano od Froyer, 01.06.2021 at 14:51

1 unit is at the same place and he removed his first wall this is a rewall

Dis

Stop rewalling neutrals.

If the original wall's units were replaced/moved it's a rewall

Rewall, huarck used to pull this crap all the time

Removing the old wall, and placing one so close to the old location, makes this a rewall

Rewall, your attack to break the city wall didnt go through because he removed the first wall. What if he now removes the big wall and makes another wall, chances are that city remains walled. Definitly rewall.

It looks like a rewall but the guy forgot how to wall.

I believe if you pick the right 3 units from that "bigwall" they will form a wall on their own.

Funny how all these mirage members come out calling it a rewall, but then when they do it, it's not a rewall

Napisano od winkcat, 02.06.2021 at 15:34

Funny how all these mirage members come out calling it a rewall, but then when they do it, it's not a rewall

That is because he is a dirty dog.

imo if i was your opponent i would take pity on you and give you credit for having enough units to actually make the big wall... which would count as NOT being a rewall... and would have the same effect on your opponent.
Its also very hard to make a big wall around London...

imo you get a pass on this one.
Voted no bcs you'll get too much heat from everyone else

Napisano od Mobster, 01.06.2021 at 15:16

The units of the new wall should be at least one city away from the walled city in my opinion.
Maybe like this: (For London, Berlin and Ankara)

Nah bro.. otherwise how tf can you reasonably expect someone to big wall ankara or kiev?

Napisano od Phoenix, 07.06.2021 at 09:48

Right, but I posted this idea so someone else can get inspired and improvise something else to make a better suggestion.

Napisano od Mobster, 07.06.2021 at 10:02

Napisano od Phoenix, 07.06.2021 at 09:48

Right, but I posted this idea so someone else can get inspired and improvise something else to make a better suggestion.

big wall is more about distance from existing 3 man wall. If your big wall is too small and the 3man is wf'ed then it should be broken if too small... for me this is a minimum of 6 units in a pentagon shape, or 7 in a hex (safer)
Croat made a wall with 7 units above which is why I'd let this one slide... Lion will recycle units from a big wall to a small wall and vice versa... he does it in his yt vids... thats a perfectly legit thing to do and it seems like what croat was trying to do here. The issue arises when you then make another 3 man wall inside... that would be a rewall